If you grew up in an English-speaking country, like I did, there's a good chance that you read The Velveteen Rabbit when you were a kid, or had it read to you. I bought a copy recently, and carried it around showing it to people. Most of them said "Oh, the Velveteen Rabbit!" or "Oooh, the Velveteen Rabbit." Only a few seemed to share my reaction, the set of feelings I associate with the name of this children's book: despair, anxiety, a nameless dread.
It's a simple, classic story. A little boy, and his favorite plush rabbit; a minor tragedy involving humans and a major one involving stuffed toys. It was the second tragedy that caught my mind -- I must have been four or five the first time I read the book -- and which made me sob with fear and a sense of creeping doom.
It's not supposed to be a sad story. Children's tales traditionally have happy endings. Since the reign of Queen Victoria, at least, and this one was no exception. But somehow the cheerful ending left no impression on my mind; no matter how many times I read it, I would always set it down with tears welling at the bottoms of my eyes.
The official ending of the Velveteen Rabbit has a syrup and saccharine taste. The "nursery magic Fairy" pops into the tale like a mechanical hand of God and rescues the forlorn rabbit; I think I must have filed this cliched little sprite away with the Easter Bunny, Santa Claus, and God, none of whom I can ever recall believing in. The tragic anticlimax of the story struck me much more deeply, and so for me it was the real ending. Until I picked the book up again last week, the fairy had vanished from my memory; I had no idea of the happy ending.
I had my own fantasy worlds to inhabit. When I was very small I began to accumulate a small community of stuffed animals, much like the rabbit of the book. They all had names, voices, personalities, hobbies, and birthdays; some of them got along with each other, but others were of more surly dispositions and got into arguments or fights. For years, I slept with them all piled around and on top of me. It was an idea I must have gotten at some forgotten point from Winnie the Pooh; I was their Christopher Robin, of course, settling disputes and telling them stories.
For a long time I felt like I cried upon every reading of The Velveteen Rabbit because I feared something similar would happen to my stuffed companions... they would be thrown out and consumed by flames, cloth and plush blackening and charring. I recall going to the city dump with my father and breaking down, imagining my stuffed skunk, Christopher, falling into one of the huge pits of waste and being lost forever among trash and refuse, crushed into a cube, buried in the earth.
But now my childhood friends all sit safely in my closet at my father's home, most of them tattered, worn, and missing quite a bit of stuffing but still intact. Now I think that perhaps I wasn't crying for fear of their fates as much as I was for my own. Although some marketing copywriter tells me on the flyleaf of my copy that the Velveteen Rabbit is about "love's power to breathe life into a toy," I know, as I have known since I first read it, that that trite phrase is only the backdrop for a story about disillusionment, despair, and death.
As the story is seen through the eyes of the rabbit, a reader naturally comes to identify with the rabbit in his quest to become "Real." The rabbit, like many people, struggles to lead an authentic life, and he seems to succeed, given meaning through his bond to a young boy; but just when things look up, his illusion of happiness is shattered, and he is thrown out on a pile of junk, forgotten almost immediately and waiting to be burned.
Such were the thoughts that rose up unknowingly in my small head when I was young. Many authors have written about the moment in their childhood when they realized the final nature of death, but I recall no such moment; it may be that awareness of death came slowly. (Later on, my voice did not break either, but gradually deepened instead. I never even noticed.) In any case, some part of me felt as if I would someday be cast out, that I would lie broken and unwanted in the midst of filth and decay, looking back mournfully at lost memories while waiting for my final destruction.
I am not and never have been a Christian, so I have no hope of a good fairy appearing to whisk me away to eternally sunlit lands; nor am I imbued with enough of the serenity of Eastern thought to enable an escape from creeping Western alienation. There may be other types of people in the world, but I am by my birth year a Rabbit. We may try to live authentic lives, and succeed without the help of fairies, but in the end we all lie wrecked and nostalgic on the trash heap, waiting for the flames.
The most pretentious homepage ever?